Determining an Exit Price for a Stock

I had a hard time when I began to invest in stocks in deciding the best price to sell my shares, exit the position and quantify my tax calculation.  Figuring out the entry point is only part of the challenge. Knowing when to get out is where returns are realized.  Until an investor is out of a position the gains are not real yet.  I’ve certainly been in that position more than a few times where I start to celebrate or even mentally spend my new profits only to see them melt away as the stock falls.

I spent time reading books and articles on how to value a stock and how the macroeconomic factors affect the price of a stock.  Before long I became overwhelmed with all of the data.  Around that time, Enron went belly-up along with a number of other corporations built on lies that didn’t make it above the fold in newspapers.  I started to wonder what was the point in pouring over all this data if it could be made up of less than accurate statements.  Even when the corporate accountants are honest, an investor has to figure out what the difference is in the bottom line and pro-forma earnings and one time write offs and tons of other screwy accounting tricks that are all actually legal.

I finally took a step back to focus on what worked for me.  Clearly all of the above criteria works for some investors, but I just couldn’t move quickly enough based on so much data.  That’s when it clicked for me.  I was already selling naked puts and covered calls which automated my exit strategy.  I realized that by spending my time focusing on an entry point and less about the exit point I could trade more often and have greater realized gains.  If I can pick the right entry point, the options I sell will get me out of the stock without using my time to second guess myself.  If I want to keep the stock I have to do all of my research again on where to enter a stock.

To me, that’s the best way to decide if you should exit a stock.  If you can say to yourself that this is a good buying point, then you should stay invested.  If you aren’t sure if you would buy the stock at the current price, get out.  I’ve never understood the analysts who rate a stock a “hold”.  Why would you hold a stock that you don’t think is going up.  All stocks should be either a buy or sell.  If you aren’t sure, then it is a “do not hold” because another stock is probably a better place to invest your cash.

Coming to this rationalization of how and when to take a profit became a major cornerstone in my investing model.  Typically I wrote covered calls after a naked put is assigned to me.  On occasion I held the stock long with no option covering it.  Sometimes I was right to do so and the stock went up giving me extra profit and sometimes it went down causing a loss of “paper profit”.  I changed my strategy to invest strictly based on premiums from options.  If assigned a stock from a naked put, I immediately sell a covered call on it the following trading day. The only decision I have to make is at what strike to sell the covered calls.  I remove the pride issue of trying to get back to even on the entire series of trades and base the strike on where the stock is trading that day.  In essence I am cutting my losses early and starting over in the process of increasing my account value again from that day forward.  That’s the final goal anyway, have more in a month from now than you do today.  Keep that in mind, don’t focus on what could have been and the higher long-term returns will come.

If you are not reading this post on you are reading it from a site that has plagiarized it.  I’ve had to add this notice to the end of every post with the growing number of scum out there who steal posts and don’t credit the authors.

Technorati Tags: , , ,

« « Understanding Downside Risks in Investing - | - Rookie Mistake: Sold Boeing (BA) Naked Put » »

* If you like this post, then consider subscribing to the Full RSS feed or email updates.

DISCLAIMER: While I am a Registered Investment Advisor Representative, the information contained within this site does not constitue personalized investment advice. This material is meant as entertainment and is only a view into how I invest my own account, but not necessarily how you should invest your own funds. Trade using your own research at your own risk. This is impersonal investment advice which means the material written here, in email exchanges, on Twitter and/or other social networking sites do not purport to meet the objectives or needs of specific individuals or accounts.

Other Popular Articles:

- How to Read an Options Table

- Determining an Exit Price for a Stock

- Understanding Downside Risks in Investing

- How Naked Put Selling Works

- 10 Tips for Keeping Emotions out of Investing


  1. Comment by vikas

    good post. enjoyed reading it.

  2. Comment by tropical animal

    Thanks for the post. I am trying to understand options trading. I have recently opened an investment account with etrade. Having made many errors in a month I am down 7% but I’ve learned a whole lot and I am determined. I have always picked the right stocks so far but I get scared in any downward movement and sell to early for the stock to mature. For example, I was in drys a couple days ago but I sold it at 103! I have no idea why. I just wanted to lock in measily gains I guess! I have a question for you. I really hope you would spend a little thought to answer.  I know your not a financial advisor but you have more money than me so I think you must have more skill also. What stock or stocks would you predict to be bullish until March of 2008. You can email me if you would like. I apprieciate the advise!

  3. Comment by Alex Fotopoulos

    Thanks for the vote of confidence. I’ll try to come up with a new list of good picks. It might be Monday before I can find some I like since my recent picks have already climbed. BA might be good soon or at least I hope so since I own 100 shares in both my IRA and taxable accounts. I’m not sure it has finished its pullback yet though. Next year should be good for it.

  4. Comment by traderbubba

    I’ve thought the same thing with regards to the analysts rating of “hold”. If the stock isn’t behaving the way it should, dump it and put your money to work on something else.

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.